Reach out to the Author

Send a message to the main author of this article with any questions you may have or to chat about anything else he or she may be able to assist you with in relation to the topic the article covers.

Nerishka Pillay

Associate - Corporate & Commercial

Barnard's current team page lists Nerishka as an Associate Attorney advising on corporate, commercial and compliance matters. She was admitted as an attorney in February 2024 and has experience in contract law, commercial litigation, legal audits and regulatory compliance.

Speak to Nerishka about this article

Contact Details
Submit

Success! We'll respond promptly to your message.

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Insight

November 19, 2026

Bringing a new investor into a company can be an exciting step. However, the way in which the investor acquires shares affects who receives the money and how the existing shareholders’ ownership changes. Selling existing shares and issuing new shares may appear similar, but they serve different purposes and have different consequences.

These transactions are governed by the Companies Act 71 of 2008, together with the company’s Memorandum of Incorporation (MOI) and any shareholders’ agreement.

‍

Selling existing shares

When a shareholder sells existing shares, they transfer some or all of their shares to a buyer. The purchase price is payable to the selling shareholder, rather than to the company. The transaction therefore allows that shareholder to receive money for their investment but does not itself raise funds for the business.

The buyer takes over the ownership represented by the shares purchased. If the seller sells all their shares, they cease to be a shareholder. If they sell only some, they remain a shareholder with a smaller interest in the company.

The total number of issued shares remains unchanged. The transaction simply changes who owns those shares. Other shareholders who do not sell or acquire shares generally retain their existing ownership percentages.

A sale of existing shares is commonly used when a shareholder wants to leave the business, reduce their involvement or realise part of the value of their investment.

‍

Issuing new shares

When a company issues new shares, the investor acquires those shares directly from the company. This is commonly called a share subscription. In a cash subscription, the subscription price is payable to the company, rather than to its existing shareholders.

The company can use the funds for purposes such as expanding its operations, purchasing equipment or funding working capital. A share issue is therefore a way of raising money for the business itself.

Unlike a sale of existing shares, a new issue increases the total number of issued shares. The investor becomes a shareholder alongside the existing shareholders, whose ownership percentages may consequently decrease.

‍

Understanding dilution

Dilution occurs when additional shares are issued and an existing shareholder’s holding represents a smaller proportion of the company’s total issued shares. The shareholder may still own exactly the same number of shares, but their percentage ownership decreases because there are now more shares in issue.

Depending on the rights attached to the shares, dilution can reduce a shareholder’s voting influence and their proportionate entitlement to dividends. It can also affect their ability to approve or block certain company decisions.

However, dilution does not automatically mean that an investment has lost value. The funds introduced by the investor may help the company grow, potentially increasing the value of the existing shareholders’ remaining interests.

Dilution can also occur when new shares are issued to an existing shareholder. The important question is whether each shareholder participates proportionately. If all existing shareholders subscribe in the same proportions as their current holdings, their ownership percentages can remain unchanged.

By contrast, a shareholder who sells existing shares reduces their holding through a voluntary transfer. The other shareholders’ percentages do not decrease merely because that sale takes place.

‍

What does the law require?

Before either transaction proceeds, the MOI and shareholders’ agreement should be checked. These documents may restrict transfers, require approvals or give existing shareholders the first opportunity to purchase shares being sold.

For new share issues, sections 38 to 40 of the Companies Act address matters such as board authority, authorised shares and the consideration the company receives. Section 39 generally gives existing shareholders of a private company an opportunity to subscribe for new shares before outsiders, subject to statutory exceptions and any limitations or exclusions in the MOI. Certain issues also require shareholder approval by special resolution under section 41.

Both transactions should be properly documented, and the company’s securities register must reflect the resulting shareholding. The rights attached to the shares should also be considered, as different classes of shares may carry different voting and financial rights.

‍

Fine Print…

The main distinction is who receives the money and whether additional shares are created. Selling existing shares generally benefits the selling shareholder financially and transfers their ownership to the buyer. Issuing new shares for cash raises funds for the company but may dilute existing shareholders. Choosing the appropriate structure requires a clear understanding of the business’s funding needs, the shareholders’ intentions and the effect on ownership and control.

Before you agree to give a new investor a stake in your business, speak to the team at Barnard about what you want the deal to achieve. We can help you structure a share sale, a subscription or a combination of the two so you know how much money will go into the business, what each selling shareholder will receive and who will have a say in future decisions.